Hi David E
I think Broad should have walked. This game should not become like others 'win at any cost'. He knew exactly what he had done.
Willy
Alas Willy, the noble "Gentleman's" game has also fallen prey to the money grabbers, posers and un-sportsmanlike predators that control modern sport of ANY kind.
Having said that, I (and most Aussies) are really pi###ed off at the way our "premium" cricketers cant seem to get their act together.
Yes, Broad should have walked, but 10 years ago, Warne or McGrath would have got him next ball...and our top order would have made enough runs to make his dismissal irelevant !!!