China Romance

General Discussion and Useful Links => Ask An Experienced Member => Topic started by: Neil on November 03, 2009, 11:29:45 pm

Title: new spin on EMF
Post by: Neil on November 03, 2009, 11:29:45 pm
I was thinking the other day.  If I ever had to start fresh with Chnlove, I wonder if something like this would work?  After 10 or so EMF's getting to know the lady and realizing that she's probably a good choice, I'd ask the translator in an EMF for direct contact.  Since I don't trust the translator, I wonder if it would make any sense to negotiate some kind of deal with them for direct contact.  I mean, the reason they keep you writing EMF's is for their income.  Say, I'll pay you $200, directly to the agency, cut out Chnlove completely, and in turn, you'll give me free and total direct contact with the lady.  You couldn't really say that in an EMF, you'd have to write to the translator's email or something, but you get the idea.  I mean, $200 is probably more than what they would rake in as profit from one person in say 3 or 4 months worth of EMF's.  And we all know, you're likely to spend $200 for EMF credits in 3 or 4 months anyway.  If not more.  

It just might work.  Thoughts?
Title: RE: new spin on EMF
Post by: Arnold on November 04, 2009, 12:21:59 am
Neil , Our Translator ( Kelly ) from Guangzhou offered us to translate under the table .. through her E-mail ( while she was at the Agency working for other's ) . But , I declined ... nicely thanking her , but I did not want to get her into trouble and loose her Job . It   sounded great of course .... but NO .
Your Plan sound good , as many other's ... like a Monthly memebership plan , where you can write as much as possible for one price . it was never even concidered by Chnlove . They like it just the way it is , otherwise they would have at least answered to those suggestion's ... but they never do . To solve this EMF deal , you must find a Lady that speaks and writes English well enough to Communicate . There is no way around it and they know it .
Title: RE: new spin on EMF
Post by: David5o on November 04, 2009, 06:31:49 am
Arnold,

You mentioned in another thread about the amount of failures that still seem to be arising from chnlove, even with the amount of information that is available on this forum. I suspect this is mainly due to the guy's not taking heed of what been written and stated here by those that have a lot more knowledge and experience. In other words they just don't listen!!

I have explained here so many times that the ladies with these agencies, all have access to an agency controlled email address, that is used by all the other outlets that these agencies have links too, as well as the ladies themselves in some instances. The chnlove EMF system is basically a bonus income for these agencies, that they try to milk for all it's worth, ie a nice little cash flow for the agency!!

I'm not going to repeat myself again here, on my idea's of getting on to the agencies normal communication link for the ladies, save to say, that once you are on the agency controlled email system, your communication via these emails becomes free. It works exactly the same as the EMF system ie, translation to and from your lady. The ladies have already paid for this service via there sign-up fee's....

So there really isn't any need to bribe the translators at the agency at all, The system is already there, up and running so to speak, the knack is to get on that system. Of course this is only one part of the problems brothers are faced with, but getting onto some sort of direct link can only be a good thing for all!!

David.....
Title: RE: new spin on EMF
Post by: Proteus on November 04, 2009, 08:41:55 am
Oh, Neil, even I am a man, I have to admit I like you more after reading such a piece of advice. The danger of your advice is propotional to the trust you place on ladies and purity of your heart. Obviously it is revealed from your so huge eagerness to get to real communication with them ASAP. So you see, even you were to eat the apple if you followed your way, you are still as pure in heart as Adam. Far opposite to David's view, I believe an innocent and naive heart is a perfect start for a successful relationship.

Most agencies, I believe, will not dare to accept such a term. The reason is simple, they are far less innocent and naive than you are. Most translator will regard it a hook and believe if they do bite the bate, severer complaint to chnlove with vital evidence will end their career and perhaps the agency's.

Then let's come to your intention. Will it really help to realise your intention if they accept such a deal? Let me explain it this way.  The more attractive the lady is, the more EMFs her account receives. Usually she will choose one or two (seldom more, in an extreme case which I know, the lady chose seven, well, a really energetic lady, I admit) candidates whom she is interested in to communicate with herself or periodically supervise the communication. The rest, if there are any, are innocent lambs for translators to deal with, whom the lady usually has no knowledge of or cares not. If you unfortunately fall into that flock, a fee to get access to the lady will not help to promote your place in the candidate list. And if you are the lucky ones, the money you pay for EMFs is a good sign of your generosity to spare her the trouble and hardship of dealing with translation herself.

Finally but formost, although it is a cruel world. Sometimes even the mere pursuit to survive, not to say thrive, presents us difficult choices to make between dignity and prosperity. I still firmly believe it is better to play clean and lose than to play dirty and win. Let's help the agencies to be clean, shall we?
Title: RE: new spin on EMF
Post by: shaun on November 04, 2009, 08:43:36 am
Quote from: 'David5o' pid='21921' dateline='1257334309'
Arnold,

You mentioned in another thread about the amount of failures that still seem to be arising from chnlove, even with the amount of information that is available on this forum. I suspect this is mainly due to the guy's not taking heed of what been written and stated here by those that have a lot more knowledge and experience. In other words they just don't listen!!

I have explained here so many times that the ladies with these agencies, all have access to an agency controlled email address, that is used by all the other outlets that these agencies have links too, as well as the ladies themselves in some instances. The chnlove EMF system is basically a bonus income for these agencies, that they try to milk for all it's worth, ie a nice little cash flow for the agency!!

I'm not going to repeat myself again here, on my idea's of getting on to the agencies normal communication link for the ladies, save to say, that once you are on the agency controlled email system, your communication via these emails becomes free. It works exactly the same as the EMF system ie, translation to and from your lady. The ladies have already paid for this service via there sign-up fee's....

So there really isn't any need to bribe the translators at the agency at all, The system is already there, up and running so to speak, the knack is to get on that system. Of course this is only one part of the problems brothers are faced with, but getting onto some sort of direct link can only be a good thing for all!!

David.....

David,

Some of us do listen. I had Pinky's email address, sent an email, but no one ever answered it. I got her daughters hotmail address, sent another email, no one ever answered it.

Though I cannot speak for everyone on this site some do try your suggestions. It is my opinion that greedy translators are the problem here and they want that gravy train flowing.  I sent Pinky's translator an email yesterday and told her when she begins to look at what went wrong in this situation to look in the mirror and she would find the source of the problem. I also told her that she gave up a marriage and translation fees for $8.00us a week.

Funny, I've not heard anything from her yet.

Shaun
Title: RE: new spin on EMF
Post by: David5o on November 04, 2009, 09:12:47 am
Proteus,

Just about the last thing you would want or need, is a naive heart for the start of a successful internet based relationship. Not unless you want it torn ,trampled, and stamped on!!!

You went on in your post to describe some of the things that go on at some of these agencies, which is why it is so important, to get to the bottom of things as far as the lady your writing too, and the honesty of the agency your having to deal with..... Going into that lion's den with a naive heart, and it's very likely that you've lost before you have even started, and not knowing it, until it's far too late to pull out unscathed....

I'm not quite sure what you mean by my View on things?? What i can tell you is, that they have been formed by listening, studying, a wealth of life's experiences, making my own mistakes along the way, and making sure not to make the same mistake twice!!  

David......

Shaun,

Yes i think your right in this case about the translator, as i told you before I've heard a few things about her in the past. I remember you posting a part of that address and it was definitely an agency controlled email address. So it could of only been your translator not servicing your email, ...There logic really fails me at times, even after all the time i spent in China, they still have the capacity to amaze!!!

It's a real shame that the Chinese acumen for business always concentrate on the small and insignificant day to day things, without taking care of the bigger picture, where the real money is always waiting.... So Sad!!!

David......
Title: RE: new spin on EMF
Post by: Proteus on November 04, 2009, 10:38:58 am
You know, David, I've very grateful to you for starting this discussion about the choice between naivety, or purity, or innocence and sophistication, or maturity or wisdom or whatsoever. You give me the chance to say something that haunts me a long time. I disappeared from this site for a couple of months, mainly because of some mental crisis. I intended to help but I feared I was disencouraging. Sometimes I'd rather I hadn't made all my posts, because I clearly know if I myself were a new member and had read the content of my posts, probably my courage to start a chnlove adventure would dissolve, and at best I'd start with a heart filled with complicated feelings. And these feelings couldn't be hidden from EMFs.

If my hasty judement could be forgiven, from my experience as a translator, those who are going to write a successful story finally are indeed those who write like Neil and Johnboy, not like you and me. The cruel fact is, as you have pointed out, they are meanwhile those who are most vulnerable to hurt and cheat.

Our opinions divide at this point. You are somewhat attributing stories of failures to not listening to or following advice from this forum, while I think except for the natural uncertainty in love affairs, most failures are attributed to and only to chnlove's dishonesty. So you see, I am surely disagreeing with you as an idealist surely will disagree with a pragmatist.

Let's say we are two kinds of fathers, you are the kind who's going to show children the cruelty of world and teach them to avoid danger and learn to survive by all means while I am the kind who wants to make the world better before show it to them. And I respect your effort anyways.

Now for something hard and perhaps a topic for new discussion. I believe if new members start their chnlove journey after reading and following our instructions, they will be safer from scams but will filter out more than they intend, and sometimes miss their true love forever. Love is an all or nothing gamble, isn't it? :icon_cool:
Title: RE: new spin on EMF
Post by: David5o on November 04, 2009, 10:50:34 am
Proteus,

Yes, i have to agree with you i am a pragmatist of sorts!! ..haha!! But then i also generally agree with most of your recent posts too, so there's hope for me yet ..lol!!

Let's just say, we are both here to give advice the best way we know how, after all, the final decision will always rest at the brothers door, whether he takes and uses that advice or he doesn't!!

So don't stop visiting this place and  giving your thoughts, it is a Forum after all, ....Right ??


David.....
Title: RE: new spin on EMF
Post by: Proteus on November 04, 2009, 11:13:14 am
Sotp visiting? Well, not until I've got married and have a child or some to offer too much diaper to wash :icon_cheesygrin:

But I'd like to make this prediction beforehead. As I have left this trade and have no intention to return, I will have less and less knowledge specificly about chnlove to give. Maybe gradually I'll post less about this topic and more about Chinese history and culture for you to share.  

recently read about some really startling Chinese wedding rituals from a 17th century story. maybe tell you later.

mid-night now here. Good night and thank you for a meaningful evening, David.
Title: RE: new spin on EMF
Post by: Neil on November 04, 2009, 05:38:59 pm
These are exactly the reasons this is such a great forum.  We have such a wealth of knowledge and a huge difference in opinion.  We have access to recent insiders and sometimes even the ladies voice their opinion.  

Thank you Proteus for your wise views.  You are right, of course.  I think now that if I had to do it over again, I would have some of my good Chinese friends introduce me to available Chinese ladies.  It would be nice to be able to fix Chnlove and make it more honest and fair, but as we all know, all's fair in love and war (money).  I'll leave it to the rest of you to try to fix them.  

I consider myself one of the lucky ones.  Lucky in that I was the one my lady chose maybe.  I'd like to think I was the best of the bunch that were writing her.  Maybe she chose me because of something I said or did that I gleaned from this website.  Likely a mix of both.  Or maybe fate, we seem to be so right for each other that it sometimes it feels like we had the help of a higher power.  I really mean that too.  If I had written down all the criteria I wanted the perfect woman to meet, I'd have a picture of her in the end.  And I do.  

[attachment=956]
Title: RE: new spin on EMF
Post by: Rhonald on November 04, 2009, 07:33:43 pm
I kneel in the presence of your wisdom Neil. Best of luck in your continued journey. And thanks for sharring the lovely picture.
Title: RE: new spin on EMF
Post by: Willy The Londoner on November 05, 2009, 02:56:09 am
I would just like to say EMF or no EMF I have had great fun getting to the point where I am today.  

If Chnlove did not exist would I be here today - I doubt it - probably in the South Tottenham Golden Oldies afternoon club and wishing I was somewhere else like China.   Like I say I am now Beyond the Dream.  

So in a small way thanks to Chnlove for being there and thanks to the translators who willingly acted as pimps in my first couple of months here!!!  Without their valuable assistance I may have had one or two lonely nights in those early months.

 But thanks to you guys whose endless wit has been a constant source of amusement.


Willy
Title: RE: new spin on EMF
Post by: shaun on November 05, 2009, 08:30:15 am
Willy,

Please don't sound like you are leaving.  Reading about your adventure or should I say quest is one of the many reasons I log in each day.  You are the kind of man that everyone likes to call friend.

Neil,

Wonderful comments.  If I had to make a choice with the options you listed I would choose that she chose me.  That would keep the flame glowing for a long, long, long, long time.

Shaun
Title: RE: new spin on EMF
Post by: Willy The Londoner on November 05, 2009, 08:55:28 am
My lady has been working from 8am until 10pm tonight so at a loss what to do as the TV has changed to digital here in Zhongshan yesterday and we need a new set box that is not coming until tomorrow.

So just been putting things on paper - getting my book ready but strayed onto the forum like I do ten times a day  - well everyones at it, writing books that is, iso why not me.

Maybe I will call it 'Jockeying For Position'  or maybe that a good title for Robs.

Willy
Title: RE: new spin on EMF
Post by: shaun on November 05, 2009, 09:03:02 am
Quote from: 'Willy The Londoner' pid='22032' dateline='1257429328'

My lady has been working from 8am until 10pm tonight so at a loss what to do as the TV has changed to digital here in Zhongshan yesterday and we need a new set box that is not coming until tomorrow.

So just been putting things on paper - getting my book ready but strayed onto the forum like I do ten times a day  - well everyones at it, writing books that is, iso why not me.

Maybe I will call it 'Jockeying For Position'  or maybe that a good title for Robs.

Willy


Mine is called "Taking the Furlong."
Title: RE: new spin on EMF
Post by: Vince G on November 05, 2009, 10:17:37 am
Quote from: 'Willy The Londoner' pid='22032' dateline='1257429328'

well everyones at it, writing books that is, iso why not me.
Maybe I will call it 'Jockeying For Position'  or maybe that a good title for Robs.


How about.... 25 meters to the outhouse by Willy Makeit?
Title: RE: new spin on EMF
Post by: brett on November 05, 2009, 10:24:11 am
Yes like Neil I also feel like one of the lucky ones. My lady chose me. I don't know (and maybe I don't really want to know) about the others she talked to through chnlove. But she touched on it in one of her early EMFs. Of all the guys she talked to I was the most honest. So there's a big clue for what these ladies are looking for. Yes we moan on this board about scammers etc., but we would probably would not believe the amount of timewasters/dishonest characters/sex tourists etc. etc. the ladies have to put up with :s.
Title: RE: new spin on EMF
Post by: Rhonald on November 05, 2009, 11:34:15 am
Quote from: 'Vince G' pid='22036' dateline='1257434257'

How about.... 25 meters to the outhouse by Willy Makeit?


Edited by Betty Wont,

and illustrated by Andy Dident
Title: RE: new spin on EMF
Post by: shaun on November 05, 2009, 12:08:36 pm
Quote from: 'Rhonald' pid='22042' dateline='1257438855'
Quote from: 'Vince G' pid='22036' dateline='1257434257'
How about.... 25 meters to the outhouse by Willy Makeit?

Edited by Betty Wont,

and illustrated by Andy Dident

The second book would be Called, A Slip in the Mud or Wet Bagger Pants

edited by Puddles B. Johnson; illustrated by Woody Downs
Title: RE: new spin on EMF
Post by: Vince G on November 05, 2009, 03:16:35 pm
Clear Plastic bikini by Seymour Hair
Title: RE: new spin on EMF
Post by: Johnboy on November 05, 2009, 09:04:08 pm
Well put Jim,

I have a great deal of respect for Proteus, and I truly believe that he is trying to help, educate and enlighten us about the pitfalls and trials and tribulations of Chnlove and, some of, its dishonest agencies and bogus, 'seeking love and marriage with a Western man' ladies.  I also believe that we must welcome and encourage Proteus to share with us his intellectuality, sensitivity and wealth of knowledge of Chnlove matters - of which, without his input, we may have very little factual or evidential knowledge.  In fact, I have come to understand that Proteus comes from a different world and perspective from us.  However, that said, your post and thoughts on this most vexaious of issues are as correct and to the point as anything I have read on this Forum since becoming a vulnerable (and, perhaps, hurt) member of it.  That is yet to be established.  Nonetheless, like Proteus, you bring a refreshing, if different, aspect to it.  Keep posting, I will keep reading and keep learning!!
Title: RE: new spin on EMF
Post by: Johnboy on November 05, 2009, 10:59:09 pm
Quote from: 'shaun' pid='21933' dateline='1257342216'

Quote from: 'David5o' pid='21921' dateline='1257334309'

Arnold,

You mentioned in another thread about the amount of failures that still seem to be arising from chnlove, even with the amount of information that is available on this forum. I suspect this is mainly due to the guy's not taking heed of what been written and stated here by those that have a lot more knowledge and experience. In other words they just don't listen!!

I have explained here so many times that the ladies with these agencies, all have access to an agency controlled email address, that is used by all the other outlets that these agencies have links too, as well as the ladies themselves in some instances. The chnlove EMF system is basically a bonus income for these agencies, that they try to milk for all it's worth, ie a nice little cash flow for the agency!!

I'm not going to repeat myself again here, on my idea's of getting on to the agencies normal communication link for the ladies, save to say, that once you are on the agency controlled email system, your communication via these emails becomes free. It works exactly the same as the EMF system ie, translation to and from your lady. The ladies have already paid for this service via there sign-up fee's....

So there really isn't any need to bribe the translators at the agency at all, The system is already there, up and running so to speak, the knack is to get on that system. Of course this is only one part of the problems brothers are faced with, but getting onto some sort of direct link can only be a good thing for all!!

David.....


David,

Some of us do listen. I had Pinky's email address, sent an email, but no one ever answered it. I got her daughters hotmail address, sent another email, no one ever answered it.

Though I cannot speak for everyone on this site some do try your suggestions. It is my opinion that greedy translators are the problem here and they want that gravy train flowing.  I sent Pinky's translator an email yesterday and told her when she begins to look at what went wrong in this situation to look in the mirror and she would find the source of the problem. I also told her that she gave up a marriage and translation fees for $8.00us a week.

Funny, I've not heard anything from her yet.

Shaun
(quote]

Shaun,

Like you, I too listen to David's advice, and very good advice it is.   Notwithstanding that, I agree with you that the major problem is greedy translators; in fact not just greedy, but corrupt, dishonest translators.  However, I think it would be equally apposite to bring your personal experience forcefully to Chnlove's attention as it has a vested interest in the loss of a marriage and a 'marriage fee' and the concurrent loss of credibility as opposed to the loss of $8.00us a week translation fees. Hopefully, the reason you have not heard from this particular translator is because that when she looked in the mirror it shattered- and in doing so slit her damn throat.
Title: RE: new spin on EMF
Post by: markymark on November 06, 2009, 05:35:33 am
I am another one that listens to what is said and try to take everything on board. It is all valuable advice and we are trying to protect ourselves and others as much as we can from bad practices or bad deeds from such perpertrators. This action puts a negative slant on contact via EMF's, you are never sure who you are really writing to. It never ceases to amaze me of their greed in making a quick few pennies in the short term and lose sight of the long term goal. Maybe they think there are plenty more men that they can scam and do not worry about such long term goals, because, by the time such goal may be achieved they will have made possibly just as much with all their quick few pennies, but surely this means they will have to work harder to attain that situation. As I said their logic defies me.
Not to go on too much but I think that maybe some men possibly do get carried away and fall into the realms of fantasy / dreams about these ladies. Yes they are beautiful / exotic looking and may be a perceived concept of an ideal lady/ partner/wife. Getting carried away with such dreams or fantasies could lead to you putting the lady on a pedastal, this can in some ways make you very vulnerable and not see red flags etc or heed good advice. All in all just be careful, go into it with eyes wide open and try the little tests to ensure valid contact as far as you are able. However, even if you do protect yourself as far as possible there is still no guarantee, all you can do is hope for the best.
Anyway these are just my thoughts and are not intended to cause any offense, good luck.
David, you made a very good comment about UK pension rights and marrying a Chinese lady, I am trying to locate that post.
Cheers.
Title: RE: new spin on EMF
Post by: shaun on November 06, 2009, 08:36:36 am
Quote from: 'Johnboy' pid='22081' dateline='1257479949'
Quote from: 'shaun' pid='21933' dateline='1257342216'
Quote from: 'David5o' pid='21921' dateline='1257334309'
Arnold,

You mentioned in another thread about the amount of failures that still seem to be arising from chnlove, even with the amount of information that is available on this forum. I suspect this is mainly due to the guy's not taking heed of what been written and stated here by those that have a lot more knowledge and experience. In other words they just don't listen!!

I have explained here so many times that the ladies with these agencies, all have access to an agency controlled email address, that is used by all the other outlets that these agencies have links too, as well as the ladies themselves in some instances. The chnlove EMF system is basically a bonus income for these agencies, that they try to milk for all it's worth, ie a nice little cash flow for the agency!!

I'm not going to repeat myself again here, on my idea's of getting on to the agencies normal communication link for the ladies, save to say, that once you are on the agency controlled email system, your communication via these emails becomes free. It works exactly the same as the EMF system ie, translation to and from your lady. The ladies have already paid for this service via there sign-up fee's....

So there really isn't any need to bribe the translators at the agency at all, The system is already there, up and running so to speak, the knack is to get on that system. Of course this is only one part of the problems brothers are faced with, but getting onto some sort of direct link can only be a good thing for all!!

David.....

David,

Some of us do listen. I had Pinky's email address, sent an email, but no one ever answered it. I got her daughters hotmail address, sent another email, no one ever answered it.

Though I cannot speak for everyone on this site some do try your suggestions. It is my opinion that greedy translators are the problem here and they want that gravy train flowing.  I sent Pinky's translator an email yesterday and told her when she begins to look at what went wrong in this situation to look in the mirror and she would find the source of the problem. I also told her that she gave up a marriage and translation fees for $8.00us a week.

Funny, I've not heard anything from her yet.

Shaun
(quote]

Shaun,

Like you, I too listen to David's advice, and very good advice it is.   Notwithstanding that, I agree with you that the major problem is greedy translators; in fact not just greedy, but corrupt, dishonest translators.  However, I think it would be equally apposite to bring your personal experience forcefully to Chnlove's attention as it has a vested interest in the loss of a marriage and a 'marriage fee' and the concurrent loss of credibility as opposed to the loss of $8.00us a week translation fees. Hopefully, the reason you have not heard from this particular translator is because that when she looked in the mirror it shattered- and in doing so slit her damn throat.

John,

I tried working through chn.  They were no help at all.  I'll save you and everyone else the boring details.

Maybe I should start a thread breaking this all down so that others could see some of the practices of agencies and chnlove.  Any comments on that?

Shaun
Title: RE: new spin on EMF
Post by: Johnboy on November 06, 2009, 08:48:30 am
Quote from: 'shaun' pid='22119' dateline='1257514596'

Quote from: 'Johnboy' pid='22081' dateline='1257479949'

Quote from: 'shaun' pid='21933' dateline='1257342216'

Quote from: 'David5o' pid='21921' dateline='1257334309'

Arnold,

You mentioned in another thread about the amount of failures that still seem to be arising from chnlove, even with the amount of information that is available on this forum. I suspect this is mainly due to the guy's not taking heed of what been written and stated here by those that have a lot more knowledge and experience. In other words they just don't listen!!

I have explained here so many times that the ladies with these agencies, all have access to an agency controlled email address, that is used by all the other outlets that these agencies have links too, as well as the ladies themselves in some instances. The chnlove EMF system is basically a bonus income for these agencies, that they try to milk for all it's worth, ie a nice little cash flow for the agency!!

I'm not going to repeat myself again here, on my idea's of getting on to the agencies normal communication link for the ladies, save to say, that once you are on the agency controlled email system, your communication via these emails becomes free. It works exactly the same as the EMF system ie, translation to and from your lady. The ladies have already paid for this service via there sign-up fee's....

So there really isn't any need to bribe the translators at the agency at all, The system is already there, up and running so to speak, the knack is to get on that system. Of course this is only one part of the problems brothers are faced with, but getting onto some sort of direct link can only be a good thing for all!!

David.....


David,

Some of us do listen. I had Pinky's email address, sent an email, but no one ever answered it. I got her daughters hotmail address, sent another email, no one ever answered it.

Though I cannot speak for everyone on this site some do try your suggestions. It is my opinion that greedy translators are the problem here and they want that gravy train flowing.  I sent Pinky's translator an email yesterday and told her when she begins to look at what went wrong in this situation to look in the mirror and she would find the source of the problem. I also told her that she gave up a marriage and translation fees for $8.00us a week.

Funny, I've not heard anything from her yet.

Shaun
(quote]

Shaun,

Like you, I too listen to David's advice, and very good advice it is.   Notwithstanding that, I agree with you that the major problem is greedy translators; in fact not just greedy, but corrupt, dishonest translators.  However, I think it would be equally apposite to bring your personal experience forcefully to Chnlove's attention as it has a vested interest in the loss of a marriage and a 'marriage fee' and the concurrent loss of credibility as opposed to the loss of $8.00us a week translation fees. Hopefully, the reason you have not heard from this particular translator is because that when she looked in the mirror it shattered- and in doing so slit her damn throat.


John,

I tried working through chn.  They were no help at all.  I'll save you and everyone else the boring details.

Maybe I should start a thread breaking this all down so that others could see some of the practices of agencies and chnlove.  Any comments on that?

Shaun


Shaun,

Only that it sounds like a very good and helpful idea.  To 'steal' from DavidE again, "knowledge is power", I think therefore that the more knowledge we acquire the more powerful we become in understanding the practices of Chnlove and the agencies from those who have experienced those practices.  I for one would welcome a thread of that nature.

John
Title: RE: new spin on EMF
Post by: Proteus on November 07, 2009, 09:59:46 am
Thank you, Jim (now I finally know how to address you), and other boys, brothers or uncles :icon_cool:

Neil, after my former replies, I felt something lingering on my mind still unexpressed and finally I caught it and would like to explain it further here. In my first reply to you I used the word "danger" without going into details. Yet what compells me to make that reply is exactly that "danger". It's dangerous in two aspects.

Although a little exaggerating, I would like to borrow David's metaphor use of lion's den here. We already know the lion is hungry and greedy. So what will happen if in certain situation we throw him some more easy feed which he does not expect, and by doing so we guarantee the shrewd and tricky lion that with some tricks to let future situations appear alike he will get similar feed again. Probably more tricks will be played, won't they?

It is more dangerous because by trying so, we are composing and setting hidden rules which might bring seemingly benefit to ourselves temporarily but harm a whole community including ourselves in the long run. The connivence of scam letters itself is already a notoriously undermining hidden rule enough, which starts with unharmful motives; at least my boss claimed so, as giving more chances to more potential couples.

Jim, I very much appreciate and enjoy reading your insights about the reality of chnlove. You vividly describe how some innocent lambs finally find their maids or, more probably, get abused with or even without their realisation. We feel apathy for them, we want to help them and by trying to do so, we meet the dilemma. This dilemma is almost about psychology.

By roughly divide the ladies' profile by success stories chnlove published in one same year, I got a answer of 4%. A very meager success rate it is. So a conclusion that scam letters and other misconducts of translators cause this low success rate is easy to reach. Surely it is. But what if the corrupted situation does not changes but people's minds change by information from this site. I dare to predict that, the success rate will be even lower. The only rational, although reluctant, advice I can give to any new member who has not started their chnlove search but are reading these words, is STOP and try elsewhere, rather than start with caution and carefulness.

To go again to my humble personal experience, say, 10 EMFs per day for a year, I've read some EMFs conveying restrained caution and subtle doubt but still trying to be polite and positive. None of them finally lead to any stories anywhere near success. With the meager 4% success rate, it proves little, since in any case, 96% EMFs are to no avail in the end. But in the 96%, those carrying caution or doubt are the first to be given up either by translators or ladies. Although this combination (yes, not only translators) dose not possess high standard of honesty, ironically, their anticipation for trust is very high. So unless you are as a fine actor as Robert De Niro, you are not very likely to seem giving your whole heart yet with essential reservation.

To be candid and self-searching, I admit my point view is strongly influenced by my character and values. I firmly believe love is an "all or nothing" thing. And I personally won't describe most translators as greedy or corrupt. After all, they are my countrymen (probably women in most cases). From my association with my former colleagues, I find they are mostly common people as I am. But are their work helpful or harmful to be calculated in all, I cannot say. What is corrupted is the generally accepted morality of this trade, which comes from indifference of the chnlove mechanism.

Buy saying that many agencies are shortsighted and a restored virtue of honesty throughout chnlove will make their business thrive, you have a comrade of opinion, Michael the China Shark whom I miss a lot. But I am not that optimistic. The barrier, in my opinion, lies in the scarcity of resource, or more plainly, the relationship between price and demand.

Since the only revenue chnlove generates is from credits, they have every reason to expect agencies to produce as many credits as possible, and meanwhile obey their rules. The public announcement of three agencies deprived authorization due to poor performance, which I think we could justifiably explain as low credits input; and the absence of any public punishment or even criticism on scam letters or other conducts, may have well suggested chnlove's emphasis. Surely it should be noted that chnlove is taking measues gradually to eliminate dishonesty in EMFs (such as the text message system).

So the ideal agency a chnlove administrator would envision is one like this, an agency that has plenty of employees to translator each letter between gentlemen and ladies, send ladies every cupid notes to respond and help them send out admiral letters. While from the aspect of revenue of an agency boss, these duties are much less important than recruiting new ladies, making phone call to them periodically reporting progress, meeting them when they come to agencies for information or merely gossip. After all, ladies are their immediate clients.

If an agency were to fulfill all the duties mentioned above ideally to satisfy both chnlove and its boss, its employees, I dare to predict again, would at least need to be doubled. And who's going to pay for the extra expense of labour? Agency bosses. I have no knowledge of financial condition of any chnlove agency, but I suspect a doubled pay bill will render most agencies into nearly no profit if not bankruptcy.

Since the extra need of employees cannot be afforded, the burden passes on. One translator is expected to do double amount of work if she's going to be a dutiful translator according to chnlove rules. But the problem is, very unfortunately, most translators do not happen to possess double amount of talent or energy or skills to fulfill the expected duty, such as the one who is writing now. So the choice is laid in front of one, it is a simple choice. Since one's scarce ability permits only fulfilling either duty levied by her boss or by chnlove, any since her pay come from her boss's pocket, I believe every one can predict her rational although pathetic decision.

So I don't want to appear kind to chnlove and say we are making effort to help them in a fiscal scale. I am quite sure our ideas will make their revenue drop, either by reducing total amount of EMFs with eliminating scam ones, or by promoting their qualification of new agency entering, which will bar some agencies out and meanwhile some ladies, their resource of credits, out. It's somewhat a war between us and chnlove. They are making money by dirty hands. This is what we want to change.

Many jobs died away or drastically shrank with history developing. Copiers laid of by Xerox is a good example. Perhaps one day, same fortune will happen to translators alike if a miraculous invention made the Babel dream come true. I don't believe chnlove will thrive in the long run. I don't even hope it. I hope it will diminish and disappear with no ill will. When some day China is as rich, civilised, and open-minded as most of your countries, when transportation development makes traveling to a country like to a city in your own country, when Chinese is as popular as English in the world or some miracle in the technique of machine translation happens, when different colours, tongues, cultures and religions are mutually blended and accepted, to meet and date a Chinese won't involve so much hardship and complication as there is today. If I were a chnlove runner then, I would gladly retire and wish every one find their true love by their own hands. All might change, but I hope the power of live remains. :icon_cool: